The lack of support from the left in the U.S. for the democracy movement in Israel is not surprising, given that many progressives view Israel as a force of evil. The Democratic Socialists of America recently proposed a resolution to make their organization anti-Zionist, and even liberal Jewish groups in the U.S. have shown little interest in the events unfolding in Israel.
Some critics argue that Israel can’t be considered a true democracy due to discrimination against Arab Israelis, its establishment as a refuge for Jews, and the ongoing occupation. However, this view misunderstands the nature of democracy, which is often imperfect and incomplete. Democracies can engage in unjust wars, support oppressive regimes, and sustain colonialism. Israel’s situation is unique because its colony, the West Bank, is right on its doorstep.
Contrary to the claims of purists, the democracy movement in Israel is a remarkable example of grassroots democracy in action. It is even more impressive considering the country’s flaws. The movement has seen massive participation, with around half a million Israelis protesting, which is equivalent to 17 million Americans. It has brought the country to a standstill, with strikes and demonstrations that involve various sectors, including doctors, big companies, lawyers, scientists, teachers, students, and more. Even former leaders from intelligence agencies have come out in support of the protests.
This movement has been consistent for over seven months, dwarfing any resistance seen in the U.S. during the Trump era. It’s important for us to be humble and recognize the significance of this ongoing movement.
The mainstream media in the U.S. has been covering the events in Israel to some extent. However, there is a tendency to depict Israel either as a country just like the U.S. or as a completely incomprehensible entity. The reality is more complex. The crisis in Israel goes beyond judicial reforms and touches on the country’s identity and deep-rooted divisions. It is not merely a conflict over legal issues; it is a battle for the soul of Israel and whether it will remain a liberal democracy or become a dictatorial theocracy.
Israel’s situation has similarities to other countries, such as the decline of social-democratic left and the rise of radical religious extremism. Parallels can also be drawn between Netanyahu and Trump, both known for their lies, attacks on the rule of law, and appeals to racism. However, we must be cautious not to overlook the unique aspects of Israel.
Israel is a small and vulnerable country surrounded by hostile neighbors. Its security concerns have shaped its national character, as a significant portion of its population serves in the armed forces. Unlike the U.S., political changes in Israel often stem from its conflicts and wars. Furthermore, Israel does not have defined borders and has ruled over the Palestinians in a state of oppression for over five decades.
In conclusion, while there are similarities between Israel and other countries, we must recognize the unique circumstances of Israel’s democracy movement. Its scale, diversity, and persistence make it a remarkable example of grassroots activism. Understanding the complexities of Israel’s situation and the challenges it faces is crucial for comprehending the significance of this ongoing movement.
Denial of responsibility! VigourTimes is an automatic aggregator of Global media. In each content, the hyperlink to the primary source is specified. All trademarks belong to their rightful owners, and all materials to their authors. For any complaint, please reach us at – [email protected]. We will take necessary action within 24 hours.