Opinion | The Implications of Autoworkers’ ‘Audacious’ Demands on American Workers: An Insightful Analysis

This transcript was created using speech recognition software. While it has been reviewed by human transcribers, it may contain errors. Please review the episode audio before quoting from this transcript and email [email protected] with any questions.

Hello! My name is Peter Coy, a writer for the Opinion section of The New York Times. I have an exciting newsletter that delves into the world of economics, business, and finance. Recently, labor unions have been making a comeback after a long period of silence. Notable organizing efforts have been seen at Starbucks, Amazon, and UPS, where drivers almost went on strike this past summer. Some are even saying that we are entering a new era of labor activism, with the “long, hot fall of labor” echoing the historic labor disputes of the past. The latest development in this trend is the United Auto Workers going on strike against the three major Detroit automakers.

Labor disputes are not only a matter between workers and management; they involve the public as well. The impact of strikes is felt by society, and public sentiment can sway in favor of either the unions or the management. Both sides are keen on changing public perception to gain support. For instance, Ford has launched an ad campaign highlighting their employment of hourly autoworkers, aiming to portray themselves as a reliable and strong employer of union workers.

The right approach to leveraging emotional cues and the inclusion of a gravelly-voiced all-American narrator in an ad like Ford’s can profoundly impact public opinion. However, their effectiveness remains uncertain due to several challenges they face. Gallup conducted a survey on people’s confidence in institutions, revealing a dismal lack of faith in big business. Even those not directly involved with labor unions have experienced the struggle of making a living while witnessing the prosperity of business owners. This has created a natural sympathy towards autoworkers and a leaning towards supporting their demands. Consequently, the United Auto Workers may find a more receptive audience in their quest to secure their demands, which are undeniably robust.

In early August, Shawn Fain, the newly elected president of the United Auto Workers Union, held a Facebook Live session where he openly addressed the rank and file. With audacity, he proclaimed their demands, an uncommon move for a negotiator who typically downplays their ambitions. Fain’s intention might lie in highlighting the sacrifices autoworkers made during the 2007-2009 global financial crisis when they accepted major concessions, including the abandonment of cost-of-living adjustments, implementation of a two-tiered wage system, reductions in retiree health benefits, and the loss of other expected perks. While the companies recovered and prospered over the past decade, the workers struggled as their pay failed to keep pace with inflation. In fact, current starting wages are lower, even adjusted for inflation, compared to 2007.

Fain’s audacious demands aim to rally the United Auto Workers, reminding them of their past sacrifices and urging them to reclaim what has been lost. This message resonates not only with union members but also with the general public who may feel left behind as wealth accumulates in the hands of a fortunate few. The negotiation process for any dispute involves determining how the benefits created jointly by both parties should be divided. The outcome can be challenging to determine, considering that the company shouldn’t receive all the value created, but the employees also shouldn’t receive all the benefits.

So, what can we expect from this ongoing negotiation? Workers find themselves in a relatively stronger position compared to the past due to a low unemployment rate, shifting public sentiment towards organized labor, and a low inventory-to-sales ratio in the auto industry. If the autoworkers achieve significant gains from this strike, similar to the favorable outcome of the UPS deal, it will inspire not only other autoworkers but workers from various industries to demand their fair share.

[MUSIC]