One of Australia’s top doctors has brought attention to a major flaw in the newly announced inquiry into the government’s response to the COVID-19 pandemic. Prime Minister Anthony Albanese and Health Minister Mark Butler officially announced the inquiry in Adelaide, but Dr. Nick Coatsworth, former deputy chief health officer, highlighted a significant omission. The terms of reference for the inquiry do not include the actions taken by state and territory governments. Dr. Coatsworth expressed concern about this omission, as it excludes the decisions made by state governments regarding border closures and lockdowns.
Dr. Coatsworth had previously called for the inquiry to examine the distribution of public health powers during a pandemic and questioned who determines the proportionality of pandemic responses. He criticized Victorian Premier Dan Andrews for focusing on vaccines, national medical stockpile, and personal protective equipment in the inquiry. Dr. Coatsworth emphasized the importance of examining the core question of proportionality.
Despite the omission of state and territory actions, Prime Minister Albanese stated that the inquiry is important and necessary. He acknowledged the dislocation, stress, and economic impact caused by the pandemic and emphasized the need to learn from the past to better prepare for future health crises. The inquiry will analyze more than 20 previous inquiries and is expected to report within twelve months.
Although the inquiry lacks the powers of a Royal Commission, it will be conducted by economist Angela Jackson, epidemiologist Catherine Bennett, and public administration expert Robyn Kruk. Prime Minister Albanese had promised a Royal Commission during his election campaign but defended the decision to opt for an inquiry, citing its efficiency and the expertise of the appointed experts.
While the opposition accuses the Albanese government of breaking its promise to hold a royal commission, Prime Minister Morrison insists that any inquiry must include both state and territory governments. He believes that a comprehensive examination of Australia’s response to the pandemic requires the involvement of all relevant parties.
Australia initially implemented strict measures such as lockdowns and border closures, which kept the country relatively COVID-free compared to other nations. However, these measures faced criticism, particularly the extended lockdown in Victoria and the isolation of Western Australia. Australia’s COVID-19 statistics, including infection rates and deaths, have worsened with the emergence of the Omnicron strain.
In summary, a top Australian doctor has raised concerns about the scope of the newly announced inquiry into the government’s pandemic response. The omission of state and territory actions has been criticized, and the need to address the proportionality of pandemic responses has been emphasized. Despite the lack of Royal Commission powers, the inquiry will be conducted by experts and is seen as a necessary step to learn from the past and prepare for future health crises.
Denial of responsibility! Vigour Times is an automatic aggregator of Global media. In each content, the hyperlink to the primary source is specified. All trademarks belong to their rightful owners, and all materials to their authors. For any complaint, please reach us at – [email protected]. We will take necessary action within 24 hours.
