Understanding the Complexities of Weight and Performance in Sport
Brock McLean, an Australian Football League (AFL) player, believed that his success as a footballer was tied to his obsession with food and weight. However, his journey led him down a dangerous path of disordered eating, guilt, and even suicidal thoughts. McLean’s story is not unique, as more athletes are facing the pressure to maintain a certain weight for performance purposes.
Recognizing the prevalence of disordered eating in sports, organizations like the AFL and AFLW have taken steps to address the issue. Skinfold testing, a common measure used to assess body composition, has been eliminated as a requirement for draft prospects. Experts are now questioning the usefulness of weight and body composition as indicators of athletic performance and overall health.
Alicia Edge, an advanced sports dietitian, highlights that the focus on weight and body composition is often based on assumptions rather than scientific research. Instead, factors like aerobic fitness and muscular power should be prioritized. The Compeat Performance team, which provides nutrition support to athletes, stopped weighing players and monitoring body composition, finding that it had a negative impact on performance and lacked clear purpose.
Professor Amanda Salis emphasizes the complexity of body size and composition, stating that it is influenced by a multitude of factors such as genetics, environment, and past experiences. She warns against simplistic solutions like “eat less or train more,” which neglect the individual behind the data.
Weight stigma also poses a risk to physical and mental health. Patients with larger bodies may avoid seeking healthcare due to feeling judged. Assuming a person’s health based on their body size can lead to disparities in healthcare access and outcomes.
Dr. Liz Sturgiss, a general practitioner, focuses on the overall well-being of her patients rather than solely relying on numbers. She highlights the importance of understanding patients’ lives and the underlying causes behind changes in weight. Weight loss, celebrated by many, may be a red flag for deeper health issues.
Ultimately, weight and body composition should not be the sole focus in sports or healthcare. A more holistic approach that considers individual circumstances, balanced nutrition, and overall well-being is crucial for optimal performance and long-term health.
Denial of responsibility! Vigour Times is an automatic aggregator of Global media. In each content, the hyperlink to the primary source is specified. All trademarks belong to their rightful owners, and all materials to their authors. For any complaint, please reach us at – [email protected]. We will take necessary action within 24 hours.
