It is often claimed that the quality of debate surrounding the upcoming referendum is lacking on both sides. However, I must disagree.
Initially, I had believed it to be in the best interest of the UK to remain in the EU. However, after carefully considering the arguments presented by Lord Owen, John Redwood, Roger Bootle, and others, I find the case for leaving to be compelling. On the other hand, the increasingly hysterical and empty arguments put forth by those advocating for remaining have led me to the conclusion that there is no positive reason to do so.
-Brian Roberts-
Torquay, Devon
In a recent episode of Question Time, Liz Truss, the Environment Secretary, stated that the EU was responsible for putting an end to the wasteful practice of throwing dead fish overboard from trawlers. However, she failed to mention that this practice was initially caused by EU law.
Now that this policy has been discarded, it is time to discard the EU as well.
-Terry Reilly-
Burgess Hill, West Sussex
James Bartholomew’s assessment of European fishing policy as damaging to the UK industry does not present the full picture.
Most fish do not adhere to national boundaries and swim in areas shared by the UK and other countries, such as the North, Celtic, and Irish seas. When national fisheries policies are implemented, overfishing and stock collapse are often observed.
The EU Common Fisheries Policy aims to ensure the sustainable sharing of a common resource among fishing nations. It sets limits on the total amount of fish that can be caught to prevent overfishing. Each country is assigned a quota based on its historical share of catching a particular species. The distribution of quotas within a national industry is determined by the respective government, not the EU. Exclusive rights to fish within a 12-mile limit of their shores are granted to all fishing nations. Beyond that, up to 200 miles, EU fishermen have access to shared resources within agreed levels due to the mobility of fish in EU waters.
While not perfect, Brussels policies have yielded positive results. Cod populations have made significant recoveries, potentially achieving sustainability once again. The UK fishing industry has been thriving, generating the highest profits in the EU and enjoying increased quotas. Additionally, one-fifth of fish caught by British vessels are landed in other EU countries’ ports. The UK also has significant influence over fishing policies.
Neither the Remain nor Leave campaigns have clearly outlined their vision for the future of British fisheries. It is crucial that the industry, fishing communities, and individuals concerned about the sea are provided with more information.
-Maria Damanaki-
Global Managing Director, Oceans, The Nature Conservancy
Former EU Commissioner for Maritime Affairs and Fisheries
London W8
Denial of responsibility! VigourTimes is an automatic aggregator of Global media. In each content, the hyperlink to the primary source is specified. All trademarks belong to their rightful owners, and all materials to their authors. For any complaint, please reach us at – [email protected]. We will take necessary action within 24 hours.
