Nearly half of all NHS hospital maternity services covered by a national inspection program have received substandard ratings, according to the findings revealed by the Observer. The Care Quality Commission (CQC), the regulatory body for healthcare providers in England, initiated the maternity inspection program last August following the Ockenden review into the Shropshire maternity scandal. This scandal involved 300 babies suffering death or brain damage due to inadequate care by the NHS.
An analysis conducted by the Observer of the CQC inspection shows that out of the 45 maternity services rated under the new program, six were deemed inadequate and another 15 were categorized as “requires improvement.” Only one service received an outstanding rating, while 23 were rated as good, with four showing improvement. The inspections prioritize safety and leadership and have revealed that approximately two-thirds of the services lack sufficient staffing, even in cases where they received an overall good rating. Furthermore, 11 services have had their rating downgraded from their previous inspections.
Dr. Suzanne Tyler from the Royal College of Midwives commented on the report, stressing the direct correlation between staffing levels and safety. She stated that the midwife shortage is worsening, with midwives working around 100,000 extra unpaid hours per week in England alone to maintain safe maternity services. Dr. Tyler called for increased funding from the government to address this issue.
Carolyn Jenkinson, the deputy director of regulatory leadership at the CQC, acknowledged that many women receive good and safe care during pregnancy, labor, and postnatally, but not everyone’s experience is positive. Issues such as inadequate staff training, weak risk assessment processes, and failure to engage with women and their families have been identified in some NHS trusts, raising concerns about service safety. She emphasized the need for hospitals to take action and invest in appropriate staffing and training to ensure consistent high-quality, safe, and personalized maternity care.
The report also mentions that prior to the pandemic, about a third of maternity services were rated as requiring improvement or inadequate. During the pandemic, the CQC targeted inspections in cases where serious risks were suspected. However, the new program intends to inspect all NHS maternity services that have not undergone assessment since April 2021.
One example of a struggling maternity service highlighted in the report is Birmingham Heartlands hospital, which is operated by University Hospitals Birmingham NHS Trust. The CQC downgraded its rating to inadequate after uncovering issues such as long waits for the pregnancy assessment emergency room and understaffing. The hospital admitted to facing significant challenges in its maternity service but assured that efforts were being made to expand the emergency room and improve staffing.
Another hospital mentioned is Poole hospital, where maternity services were also downgraded to inadequate due to shortages of midwifery and medical staff. The CQC report highlighted that midwifery staffing levels affected the safety of the maternity unit, which had to close several times in the past year due to staffing challenges. The hospital acknowledged these issues and stated that improvements had been implemented, including reduced triage waiting times.
The University Hospitals Dorset NHS Foundation Trust, responsible for Poole hospital, explained that staffing problems were prevalent across the entire NHS and stated that measures had been taken to address the issues. The Department of Health also responded, highlighting the ongoing efforts to improve the quality of care and increase the number of available midwifery posts through additional funding.
In conclusion, the findings underline the pressing need to address the substandard conditions in NHS hospital maternity services. The CQC’s inspection program aims to enhance safety and leadership, and improvements in staffing and training, as well as increased funding, are necessary to ensure high-quality, safe, and personalized care for expectant mothers.
Denial of responsibility! VigourTimes is an automatic aggregator of Global media. In each content, the hyperlink to the primary source is specified. All trademarks belong to their rightful owners, and all materials to their authors. For any complaint, please reach us at – [email protected]. We will take necessary action within 24 hours.
