An ’embarrassing’ study claiming that Covid vaccines increase the risk of dying from heart problems has sparked anger online. This study, conducted by three US academics, analyzed two previous studies and found that there were higher rates of cardiac-related deaths among vaccine recipients. However, independent experts have criticized the paper for relying heavily on a controversial study that has been deemed ‘incredibly flawed’ and a ‘political exercise’. Others have called the analysis ‘largely pointless’ and a ‘tool for misinformation’.
Significant studies have already debunked claims that Covid vaccines have led to an increase in deaths from heart problems. data from the Office for National Statistics (ONS) shows that rates of cardiovascular deaths in men in England over time. Rates for younger men spiked in 2020, before the vaccines were introduced, and then returned to pre-pandemic levels. A 2022 study led by researchers at Imperial College London suggests that Covid vaccines saved nearly 20 million lives in the first year of their rollout, with the majority of lives saved in wealthy countries.
The peer-reviewed paper, published in Human Vaccines & Immunotherapeutics, aimed to ethically assess the safety of vaccination. The researchers acknowledged the significant role that Covid vaccines have played in controlling the pandemic and saving lives. However, they also noted that there have been reports of various adverse events linked to vaccines produced by companies like Pfizer and Moderna. While most side effects are mild and temporary, including arm pain, fatigue, and headaches, some individuals have experienced heart inflammation and blood clots, although these instances are rare.
The researchers, led by Dr. Greg Marchand, an obstetrician-gynecologist in Arizona, initially examined three studies that included data from 750,000 patients. These studies, conducted in the US, UK, and Italy, aimed to analyze the risk of death among individuals who had recently received a Covid vaccine. However, the researchers chose to exclude the Italian study, which found no increase in mortality within a month of vaccination. The discrepancy between this study and the other two raised concerns about the reliability of the findings. As a result, the analysis was weighted to prioritize the results of the US study, accounting for over 90% of the new findings.
The results of the analysis showed no overall link between receiving a Covid vaccine and all-cause mortality. However, individuals who had recently been vaccinated had a 6% higher risk of death from heart problems within six months. This link was even stronger when looking specifically at men, who had a 9% higher risk. The researchers concluded that there may be a small increase in cardiac-related mortality associated with Covid vaccination, especially among males.
However, the US study that formed the basis for this new paper has itself been heavily criticized for being ‘incredibly flawed’. The study, posted online by the Florida Department of Health in October 2022, suggested an 84% higher risk of death from myocarditis among men aged 18 to 39 who had been vaccinated. However, the study did not account for individuals who had tested positive for Covid, which can also cause heart inflammation and related issues. The study also lacked author attribution and had not undergone peer review. Despite these concerns, Dr. Joseph Ladapo, the state’s surgeon general, and a vaccine skeptic, used the study to support his call for men aged 18 to 39 to avoid Covid vaccination.
The authors of the new study acknowledged these concerns but found no evidence challenging the validity or quality of their own findings. Dr. Marchand claimed that their paper confirms the link between cardiac-related mortality and Covid vaccination. However, healthcare professionals have criticized the study’s findings. Dr. Tyler Black, a child and adolescent psychiatrist at the University of British Columbia, called the paper ’embarrassingly bad’ and accused the researchers of downplaying the overall improvement in all-cause mortality that would have been found in a proper meta-analysis. He emphasized that relying heavily on one study provides no value and can lead to biased findings. Professor Jeffrey Morris, a statistical data scientist at the University of Pennsylvania, commented that it is not surprising that the analysis confirmed the results of the US study since it failed to effectively incorporate information from other papers. Dr. Gideon Meyerowitz-Katz, an epidemiologist in Sydney, described the analysis as ‘largely pointless’ due to its inclusion of only two studies, one of which he deemed a political exercise. He also criticized the researchers for selectively choosing the statistical model used for their analysis, making the findings dependent on a single arbitrary decision.
Similar theories have been used to explain an increase in heart-related deaths associated with vaccines. However, real-world evidence shows that the majority of vaccine-induced cases of myocarditis are mild, with patients making a full recovery shortly after symptoms appear, usually within a week of vaccination, according to the British Heart Foundation. Globally, Covid vaccines have been credited with saving nearly 20 million lives in their first year of deployment. Nevertheless, like any medication or vaccine, there are risks associated with the vaccines, most of which are mild, such as sore arms, flu-like symptoms, and headaches. In extremely rare cases, vaccines have been found to trigger myocarditis and pericarditis, inflammation of the heart, particularly among young people. However, leading heart experts stress that the majority of cases are mild and temporary, and point out that contracting the virus itself can also lead to these conditions.
To address concerns around the vaccine’s impact on heart health, two leading experts in cardiology, Professor Amitava Banerjee and Dr. Martin Lowe, have debunked the biggest myths. They confirm that there has been an increase in heart-related deaths since 2020, not driven by the virus itself but by the disruption to heart care services during the pandemic. Regarding the vaccine’s effect on the heart, they acknowledge the rare cases of myocarditis and pericarditis but emphasize that these cases are typically mild, with most individuals experiencing complete recovery. They assure the public that the vaccines have been thoroughly tested and are safe for individuals with heart conditions or taking heart medications.
Overall, while this study claiming a link between Covid vaccination and cardiac-related mortality has generated controversy, experts have criticized its methodology and reliance on flawed previous studies. They assert that the overwhelming evidence supports the safety and effectiveness of Covid vaccines in preventing severe illness and deaths.
Denial of responsibility! VigourTimes is an automatic aggregator of Global media. In each content, the hyperlink to the primary source is specified. All trademarks belong to their rightful owners, and all materials to their authors. For any complaint, please reach us at – [email protected]. We will take necessary action within 24 hours.
