A teacher in Georgia’s Cobb County School Board was fired after a controversial incident involving the reading of a book on gender fluidity to her fifth-grade class. The board voted 4-3, going against the recommendation of a panel of retired educators who believed that the teacher, Katie Rinderle, should not be fired. Rinderle, a ten-year veteran, faced criticism in March for reading the picture book My Shadow Is Purple by Scott Stuart at Due West Elementary School. Some parents were unhappy with this choice and complained about it.
This case has garnered significant attention as it raises questions about the freedom of public school teachers to teach, the extent of control school systems have over teachers, and whether parents have the power to veto instructional material they dislike. Rinderle did not comment after the vote but released a statement through the Southern Poverty Law Center, one of her legal representatives. In the statement, Rinderle argued that “the district is sending a harmful message that not all students are worthy of affirmation in being their unapologetic and authentic selves.” She further expressed concern that the decision, based on vague policies, would lead to self-censorship among teachers. The district policy was implemented last year.
The decision to fire Rinderle was heavily influenced by party lines, with the four Republican board members voting in favor of her termination and the three Democrats opposing it. Initially, Superintendent Chris Ragsdale, supported by the Republican majority, recommended firing Rinderle. In response to the decision, the district emphasized its commitment to keeping classrooms focused on teaching, learning, and student success. Rinderle’s lawyer, Craig Goodmark, argued that the policy was so ambiguous that Rinderle could not have known what was not allowed, a point supported by the hearing tribunal’s refusal to agree with the claim that Rinderle knowingly violated policies. Rinderle has the option to appeal her firing to the state Board of Education and potentially pursue legal action. Goodmark expressed confidence that Rinderle will find employment as a teacher elsewhere. “She will be a teacher again,” he stated.
(Read more teacher firing stories.)