When you make a purchase using the links on our website, Insider may earn a commission as an affiliate. We believe in providing our readers with valuable information and recommendations, which is why I, as a sleep reporter with extensive experience testing over 70 mattresses, can confidently say that the price you pay for a mattress is often reflective of its quality. Generally, we advise our readers to invest a minimum of $1,000 in a mattress. However, if your budget doesn’t allow for that, there are still some great options available under $500.
After thoroughly testing 11 mattresses, I found that the Allswell Mattress stood out as the best affordable choice that is readily accessible. It must be noted, though, that like any other product, it does have its drawbacks. In this review, I’ll share my experiences with the flagship mattress from Walmart’s Allswell brand, providing insights from sleeping on it for 14 nights and subjecting it to our battery of objective tests.
Design and Specifications:
– Best for: Stomach and back sleepers, cold sleepers, couples
– Available sizes: Twin, twin XL, full, queen, king, Cal king
– Mattress type: Hybrid
– Firmness (1 being the softest and 10 being the firmest): 7
– Motion isolation (1 being awful and 10 being the best): 7
– Heat dissipation (1 trapping heat and 10 staying cool): 4
– Edge support (1 being awful and 10 being the best): 7
– Trial period: 100 nights
– Warranty: 10 years
– Weight: 81.7 pounds
– Thickness: 10 inches
– Shipping and returns: Free shipping and returns
– White glove delivery and mattress removal: Not available
– Showroom availability: Not available
Our Review of the Allswell Mattress:
Set Up:
The Allswell mattress arrives at your doorstep in a box approximately the size of a mini-fridge. While it doesn’t come with explicit instructions, it’s easy enough to figure out that you need to open the box and remove the plastic packaging to allow the vacuum-sealed mattress to expand. I recommend using a letter opener or a similar tool to cut through the plastic without damaging the mattress.
The setup process took me a mere five minutes. At 82 pounds, the Allswell is lighter than the average weight of the mattresses I’ve tested, which is around 105 pounds. This made the setup process much simpler. However, it’s worth noting that 82 pounds might still be challenging to handle for some individuals. Unfortunately, unlike many other mattress-in-a-box companies, Allswell does not offer an in-home setup service.
Upon unboxing the mattress in the morning, I detected a mild “new bed smell.” However, by the time I went to bed, the odor had dissipated and the mattress had expanded to its full size.
Construction:
The Allswell Mattress sets itself apart from most sub-$500 mattresses by incorporating a hybrid construction. While many mattresses in this price range are made entirely of foam, the Allswell mattress combines pocket coils or springs with foam. This hybrid design offers the benefits of both materials.
The top layer of the Allswell mattress consists of CertiPUR-US-certified memory foam infused with charcoal and copper gel. This combination is intended to provide cooler sleep. The mattress also features individually wrapped coils for improved airflow, durability, motion isolation, and support. Additionally, there is a quilted panel on the top layer, which can be cleaned with mild detergent and warm water. For more information on cleaning mattresses, refer to our article on the topic.
Comfort:
The Allswell mattress has a medium-firm level of firmness, which means it is firmer than most mattresses but not overly firm. I personally found it most comfortable when sleeping on my stomach or back. However, I must admit that the firmness was too intense for me to sleep comfortably on my side.
To track my sleep quality, I wore the Garmin Forerunner 945 watch while sleeping. It provided me with a sleep score each morning based on my REM, restless, deep, and overall sleep cycles. Throughout my testing of the Allswell mattress, I noticed an improvement in my sleep quality, surpassing my average experience and outperforming other cheap mattresses I tested. Objectively, the mattress facilitated better sleep.
Subjectively, there were moments during the night when I woke up. Nevertheless, I had no trouble falling back asleep, and I consistently woke up feeling refreshed. Remarkably, despite my current marathon training and the physical stress that comes with it, my body was mostly pain-free.
Heat Dissipation:
To assess the heat dissipation of the Allswell mattress, I conducted objective tests using a laser thermometer. I measured the surface temperature of the mattress before going to bed and upon waking up. Two minutes later, I took another reading to evaluate the mattress’s ability to dissipate heat. The Allswell mattress was found to retain more heat and become warmer compared to most other mattresses. During my test, the temperature increased by 20 degrees Fahrenheit, from 67 degrees to 87 degrees, while I lay on it. Moreover, it only exhibited an 11-degree decrease in temperature during the dissipation phase, whereas the average decrease among other mattresses was 13 degrees. There were some nights during my testing when I felt as though I was overheating on the Allswell.
Edge Support:
One important factor to consider in a mattress is its edge support, which plays a significant role in comfort, particularly for individuals sharing a bed. The Allswell mattress excels in this regard due to its supportive coils. When sitting on the edge, I measured a 3.5-inch dip, which is consistent with the average among other mattresses I’ve tested. However, when lying on the edge, the support was even more pronounced. I felt completely supported and had to roll quite far before actually falling off.
Motion Isolation:
Another crucial aspect to consider, especially for couples, is motion isolation. The Allswell mattress performed well in this regard. I conducted two tests to evaluate motion isolation. The first involved dropping a bowling ball from a height of 4 feet so that it landed a foot away from a soda can. If the can remained upright, it indicated excellent motion dampening. Conversely, if the can fell over, it showed that there is room for improvement. For the second test, I placed a vibrometer on the opposite side of the bed to measure the vibrations caused by the falling bowling ball. I then compared these readings to those of other mattresses.
Based on these tests, the Allswell mattress demonstrated good motion isolation. It passed the bowling ball test around half the time and registered a vibrometer score of 7.1, which is higher than average. Most mattresses that perform well in motion isolation tend to lack bounce. However, the Allswell strikes a balance between the two, which makes it an excellent choice for couples.
Trial Period and Warranty:
Allswell offers a generous trial period of 100 nights for you to try out the mattress risk-free. If you find that the mattress isn’t suitable for you, you can return it for a full refund. Additionally, the mattress is backed by a 10-year warranty. However, it’s essential to be aware of certain conditions:
– The warranty is only valid if you use the mattress on an appropriate foundation, such as slatted wood or metal foundations with slats no more than 4 inches apart, wood or metal box foundations, and solid wood or metal platforms, including adjustable bases.
– The warranty will be void if you remove the “do not remove this tag under penalty of law” tag.
On the positive side, Allswell covers the shipping costs for warranty replacements, which is not a common practice among manufacturers.
Alternatives:
If you have a maximum budget of $500, the Allswell mattress is an ideal choice for back and stomach sleepers, couples, and those who tend to sleep cold. However, if you don’t fall into any of these categories, our comprehensive guide to the best cheap mattresses offers a wide range of recommendations tailored to specific needs. For example, side sleepers may prefer the softer feel of the Siena Memory Foam Mattress, which provides excellent motion isolation, edge support, and heat dissipation.
For those with a budget of $700, we recommend the Nectar Mattress. It has an average firmness that caters to all sleep styles, exceptional edge support, excellent motion isolation, and heat dissipation. Furthermore, it comes with a 365-night trial period and a lifetime warranty. For more information, read our detailed review of the Nectar Mattress.
Conclusion:
During my testing, I found the Allswell Mattress to be most comfortable for back and stomach sleepers. It is undoubtedly the best mattress I have tested in the affordable price range of under $500. I experienced exceptional sleep quality on this mattress. Its firmness level is optimal for those who sleep on their stomach or back, and couples will appreciate the motion isolation and edge support it offers. Of course, with a mattress at this price point, there are bound to be some downsides, and the Allswell is no exception. However, the company offers a 100-day return policy, allowing you to obtain a full refund if the mattress doesn’t meet your expectations. So if you’re looking for a high-quality mattress without breaking the bank, the Allswell Mattress is a great option to consider.
Denial of responsibility! VigourTimes is an automatic aggregator of Global media. In each content, the hyperlink to the primary source is specified. All trademarks belong to their rightful owners, and all materials to their authors. For any complaint, please reach us at – [email protected]. We will take necessary action within 24 hours.
