SAN FRANCISCO — Following the San Diego Padres’ elimination from the 2006 National League Division Series, Bruce Bochy returned home only to be informed that his contract would not be extended beyond the 2007 MLB season. Sandy Alderson, the then-CEO of the Padres, gave Bochy the go-ahead to explore other opportunities. Shortly thereafter, Bochy found himself in San Francisco, receiving a tour of the city from Brian Sabean, the Giants’ general manager at the time.
During their conversations, lasting several hours, Bochy and Sabean discussed life and their shared perspective on the game. A few days later, Sabean called Bochy and extended an invitation: “We’d love to have you up here.”
Now, seventeen years later, the Giants are hoping to replicate the success that followed that phone call.
On Wednesday, the Giants will officially introduce Bob Melvin as their next manager. After a whirlwind process, which began with the Padres allowing talks between the Giants and Melvin despite him being under contract, the 61-year-old will replace Gabe Kapler and lead the organization in a new, yet familiar, direction.
The decision to hire Melvin came after a lengthy search process, both internally and externally. However, Melvin was always the preferred candidate.
Even before Kapler’s dismissal, Melvin’s name was frequently surfacing within the industry. Towards the end of September, as the Padres’ disappointing season neared its end, reports emerged suggesting that Melvin and Padres president of baseball operations, A.J. Preller, had irreparable issues. While Preller attempted to debunk the rumors during a later media briefing, stating that “Bob is our manager,” the Giants never believed it was set in stone.
The Giants extensively interviewed internal candidates Kai Correa, Mark Hallberg, and Alyssa Nakken. They also spoke with recently retired players such as Stephen Vogt and Nick Hundley, and reached out to others in the league. Yet, the front office’s focus remained fixed on Melvin.
For the three-time Manager of the Year, this represents a homecoming. And for the Giants, it signifies a move that aligns with their immediate goals.
Melvin, a Bay Area native with over 1,500 managerial wins, returns to the area where he was born, grew up, and attended Cal and Cañada College. He played ten MLB seasons, including three with the Giants alongside teammates like Mike Krukow and Will Clark.
In every aspect, Melvin’s local ties, experience, and stature in the game make him a logical choice. As the Giants head into one of their most consequential offseasons, stability in a key position is crucial.
While the Giants plan to remain at the forefront of analytics, preparation, and training advancements, they have recognized the need to prioritize star power and everyday players. In hiring Melvin, they demonstrate a desire for more autonomy in the manager’s office.
Under different circumstances, the Giants might have opted for a promising young coach like Correa, Hallberg, or Vogt. They could have made history by choosing Nakken. However, their current focus is stability for 2024, when numerous jobs will be on the line. Melvin will provide that stability from the moment he steps into Oracle Park.
This will be Melvin’s fifth managerial stop and third in the NL West. His arrival follows in the footsteps of another former A’s employee, Farhan Zaidi, who came to the Giants five years ago. Zaidi was given the freedom to build a team with a specific style. Additionally, he was allowed to choose a manager who faced opposition from fans and even some within the organization.
Zaidi and Kapler implemented nontraditional strategies, constructing rosters around overlooked players while utilizing platoons and bulk innings pitchers. Although phrases like “line change” and “featured guy” were introduced, the organization realized they may have attempted too much, too quickly.
The Giants remain committed to being innovative through analytics, preparation, and training. However, they now acknowledge the importance of prioritizing star players and everyday talent. By hiring Melvin, they signal a need for more independence in the manager’s office.
As the Giants target high-profile acquisitions like Shohei Ohtani, Yoshinobu Yamamoto, and Jung Hoo Lee, Melvin’s presence should prove invaluable. Widely respected throughout the game, Melvin has ample experience managing Japanese superstars, having worked with Ichiro Suzuki and Yu Darvish.
The Giants’ pursuit of Lee is partly influenced by the success of his former teammate, Ha-Seong Kim, in San Diego. Melvin played a significant role in Kim’s development over the past two seasons.
Questions may arise concerning Melvin’s ability to lead the Giants to the postseason, given his inability to do so with the underperforming Padres. Additionally, concerns about clubhouse dynamics emerge, as San Diego partially fired their manager due to those concerns.
However, the Giants are not overly worried about the 2023 San Diego Padres. Zaidi takes a long-term perspective, and Melvin’s track record includes 20 seasons of exceeding expectations. While the 2023 Padres might have endured turmoil, it is worth noting that the Giants’ clubhouse dynamics differ from those in San Diego, which faced ongoing issues predating Melvin’s arrival.
In his new role, Melvin will not have to cater to oversized egos. Instead, he will lead a clubhouse desperately in need of guidance and firm direction. With two decades of managerial experience, Melvin’s credibility is undeniable.
Buster Posey, who participated in the interview process, supports Melvin’s hiring. The team’s current clubhouse leaders are also reportedly pleased with the decision.
Following permission to interview Melvin, the Giants acted swiftly to finalize their choice. Although teams are generally discouraged from making significant announcements during the playoffs, the Giants will introduce Melvin during the World Series break. They wanted to conclude their search well ahead of the offseason to focus on pursuing players like Ohtani, Yamamoto, and others. As a result, they succeeded, securing their preferred manager from the beginning.
Download and follow the GiantsTalk Podcast
