Full spoilers follow for Doctor Who: “The Star Beast.”
As Doctor Who’s 60th-anniversary special unfolds, we’re reminded of the tragic undertones overshadowing the celebratory occasion. This special sees the return of David Tennant, fans’ beloved Doctor, for three specials. The first of these debuted on Disney+ and BBC One, featuring writer-producer Russell T Davies, the mastermind behind the series’ revival in 2005.
The Doctor gives a quick “previously on” direct-to-camera in “The Star Beast,” highlighting Donna’s lack of memory from her time with him. She seems haunted by a sense of longing and loss, despite living a normal life back on Earth.
Donna’s feelings mirror those of Sarah Jane Smith, a former companion, and illustrate the wider paradox of the Doctor’s immortal existence, showcasing the bittersweet reality that accompanies the Doctor’s companions once their adventures conclude.
At times, it feels as if Donna’s memory wipe may have been a blessing, sparing her from the sorrow of remembering what she lost. This dilemma deeply resonates with the Doctor’s complex and enduring loneliness, hinting at the difficult reality of his timeless existence and the inevitable separations he faces from his companions.
Ultimately, the Doctor’s immortality adds a layer of complexity and paradox to his character, as it condemns him to witness the fleeting moments of his companions’ lives. Far from making matters easier, freedom from the memory wipe further highlights the emotional struggles that come with the Doctor’s companions realizing what they’ve lost.
Follow Executive Editor Scott Collura on Twitter at @ScottCollura, or tune in to his Star Trek podcast, Transporter Room 3. Or do both!
